CELF Advisors LLP
Climate Impact & Sustainability Data (2011, 2012, 2017, 2019, 2020-01 to 2020-12, 2021-01 to 2021-12, 2022, 2023)
Reporting Period: 2011
Environmental Metrics
ESG Focus Areas
- Environmental
- Social
- Governance
- Responsible Investing
Environmental Achievements
- Reduced costs by approximately $1.8 million per year and eliminated about 5,000 metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions and 440,000 pounds of waste annually at NBTY through EcoValuScreen.
- More than 60 companies across Carlyle's portfolios evaluated their operations according to the PEGCC guidelines (representing more than 90% of Carlyle's controlled, corporate buyout investments).
- Applied EcoValuScreen to five transactions.
- H.C. Starck developed a clean supply chain process, certified by Bureau Veritas, ensuring products do not use minerals sourced from conflict regions.
- Implemented Energy Star-compliant computers and virtualization of data centers to reduce energy consumption.
- Opened a new eco-friendly office in Rosslyn, Virginia.
Social Achievements
- Launched Charter Board Partners (CBP), a nonprofit organization that teams local professionals with charter schools.
- Numerous events with Junior Achievement and Habitat for Humanity.
- Launched a matching program in the UK for employee donations to eligible charities.
- Launched the Toigo Private Equity MBA Graduate Fellowship to attract minority MBA graduates.
Governance Achievements
- More than 90% of the boards of Carlyle's controlled, corporate buyout companies reviewed the PEGCC guidelines.
- Formed working partnerships with PGGM and APG, two Dutch pension fund asset managers, to improve ESG practices.
- Integrated discussions of ESG issues into key professional development sessions.
Climate Goals & Targets
- Not disclosed
- Apply environmental sustainability principles to US Real Estate investments.
- Sharpen focus on social issues in Sub-Saharan Africa.
- Enhance focus on the 'S' in ESG.
- Integrate sustainability considerations into US Real Estate investment decisions.
- Develop appropriate metrics to measure progress.
Environmental Challenges
- Integrating sustainability considerations into investment decisions.
- Developing appropriate metrics to measure progress on initiatives.
- Addressing social issues, particularly in Sub-Saharan Africa.
- Expanding efforts to share responsible investment guidelines with portfolio companies.
Mitigation Strategies
- Developed EcoValuScreen with EDF to evaluate target companies and identify ways to enhance environmental operations.
- Established a new investment team to target opportunities in Africa, focusing on social issues.
- Worked with experts like EDF, APG, and PGGM to share ideas and best practices on ESG integration.
- Integrated ESG discussions into professional development programs.
Supply Chain Management
Responsible Procurement
- H.C. Starck's conflict-free sourcing process.
Climate-Related Risks & Opportunities
Opportunities
- Energy efficiency improvements in portfolio companies.
Reporting Standards
Frameworks Used: PEGCC Guidelines for Responsible Investment, UN Principles for Responsible Investment, UN Global Compact, Walker Guidelines (UK), BVK Guidelines (Germany)
Certifications: ISO 14001 (implied by some portfolio company actions), Energy Star
Sustainable Products & Innovation
- Veyance Technologies' Eagle NRG belt.
- Talaris NMD 100 bill-dispensing unit.
Awards & Recognition
- Foreign Policy Association’s 2010 Corporate Social Responsibility Award
Reporting Period: 2012
Environmental Metrics
ESG Focus Areas
- Responsible Investing
- Environmental Stewardship
- Corporate Governance
- Community Volunteering
- Workplace Diversity
Environmental Achievements
- Reduced greenhouse gas emissions by over 31,000 metric tons across more than a dozen portfolio companies, resulting in over $7 million in savings.
- Reduced water usage by 15 million gallons at Allison Transmission.
- Achieved a 10% increase in recycling at Allison Transmission.
- Aurora Place achieved 30% energy savings through improvements.
Social Achievements
- Carlyle matched over $190,000 in employee charitable contributions.
- Hosted the first Sustainability Roundtable for portfolio companies.
- Launched Global Volunteer Month with 12 events in six locations.
- Contributed $185,525 to the American Red Cross after Hurricane Sandy.
- Highest proportion of female executives (13%) among alternative asset management firms.
Governance Achievements
- Developed responsible investment guidelines, influencing the Private Equity Growth Capital Council (PEGCC) guidelines.
- Shared responsible investment guidelines with over 70 portfolio companies (90% of controlled companies).
- Integrated ESG considerations into investment decision-making process.
Climate Goals & Targets
- Not disclosed
- Not disclosed
- Not disclosed
Environmental Challenges
- Assessing and mitigating ESG risks associated with corporate investments.
- Potential negative effects of low-probability, high-impact ESG risks.
Mitigation Strategies
- Developed responsible investment guidelines.
- Integrated PEGCC guidelines into investment decision-making.
- Shared guidelines with portfolio companies for annual review.
- Used EcoValuScreen to identify environmental management opportunities.
Supply Chain Management
Supplier Audits: Not disclosed
Responsible Procurement
- Not disclosed
Climate-Related Risks & Opportunities
Physical Risks
- Not disclosed
Transition Risks
- Not disclosed
Opportunities
- Not disclosed
Reporting Standards
Frameworks Used: UN Principles for Responsible Investment, UN Global Compact
Certifications: Null
Third-party Assurance: Not disclosed
UN Sustainable Development Goals
- Not disclosed
Not disclosed
Sustainable Products & Innovation
- PQ Corporation's zeolites for catalytic converters
Awards & Recognition
- Not disclosed
Reporting Period: 2017
Environmental Metrics
ESG Focus Areas
- Value creation
- Robust governance and transparency
- Industry leadership on ESG issues
Environmental Achievements
- Carlyle, across its 31 global offices and 1,600 employees, became carbon neutral in 2017.
- 15.9% reduction in data center energy use.
- New London office certified "Excellent" by BREEAM.
- U.S. offices earned LEED and Energy Star certifications.
Social Achievements
- Received a perfect score of 100 from the Human Rights Campaign for LGBTQ inclusiveness.
- Global mentoring program engaged over 500 participants.
- Numerous employee resource groups hosted nearly 120 events.
Governance Achievements
- 96% of Carlyle-controlled companies reviewed operations in accordance with Guidelines for Responsible Investment.
- Carlyle Europe Partners implemented enhanced ESG framework with company-by-company ESG KPI reporting.
Climate Goals & Targets
Environmental Challenges
- Identifying and managing ESG risks across a diverse portfolio of companies.
- Quantifying the impact of ESG initiatives.
- Ensuring consistent ESG practices across global operations.
Mitigation Strategies
- Tailored ESG strategies for each portfolio company.
- Use of SASB sector guidelines to identify material ESG issues.
- Regular training for employees on ESG issues.
- Engagement of external experts for ESG assessments.
Supply Chain Management
Climate-Related Risks & Opportunities
Physical Risks
- Extreme weather events
Reporting Standards
Frameworks Used: SASB, UN Principles for Responsible Investment, UN Global Compact, Global Reporting Initiative
Certifications: LEED, Energy Star, BREEAM, ISO 14001
UN Sustainable Development Goals
- Goal 8 (Decent Work and Economic Growth)
- Goal 9 (Industry, Innovation and Infrastructure)
Investments in companies that create jobs and improve infrastructure.
Reporting Period: 2019
Environmental Metrics
ESG Focus Areas
- Diverse and inclusive teams
- Engaged employees
- Sustainable growth
- Climate resilience
- Stronger communities
Environmental Achievements
- Carlyle became the first major private equity firm to go carbon neutral in 2018.
- In 2019, Carlyle cut greenhouse gas emissions by nearly 3%, water withdrawal by 2.5%, and diverted 83% of non-hazardous waste from landfill across its global facilities operations.
- Accolade Wines achieved a 44% reduction in CO2e emissions from its Bristol facility in the 12 months to March 2020.
- Neptune Energy's carbon intensity is one of the lowest in the industry (5.8kg of CO2 per boe in 2019).
Social Achievements
- Launched a Global Mentoring Program with over 800 participants.
- Conducted first firm-wide employee engagement survey.
- Established Employee Resource Groups (ERGs).
- Partnered with Year Up, providing internships and employment opportunities.
- Co-sponsored the Private Equity Veterans Initiative Summit.
- Improved diversity metrics (44% female employees, 50% female hires in 2019).
Governance Achievements
- Increased transparency and detail of corporate ESG disclosures through GRI and SASB disclosures.
- Established an internal carbon price for risk assessments and investment decisions.
- Implemented an ESG-linked term loan for Jeanologia, linking pricing to water savings targets.
Climate Goals & Targets
- Not disclosed
- Not disclosed
- Not disclosed
Environmental Challenges
- Addressing climate change and its impact on businesses.
- Improving diversity and inclusion across the organization and portfolio companies.
- Collecting and utilizing ESG data effectively.
- Balancing company-specific ESG work with broad-based portfolio-wide action.
Mitigation Strategies
- Investing in renewable energy projects (Cardinal Renewables).
- Partnering with portfolio companies to drive measurable change on material ESG issues.
- Setting ambitious goals for systemically important issues (e.g., board diversity).
- Developing new approaches to driving impact (e.g., ESG-linked financing).
Supply Chain Management
Supplier Audits: Not disclosed
Responsible Procurement
- Appointment of Chief Procurement Officer to drive accountability.
Climate-Related Risks & Opportunities
Physical Risks
- Not disclosed
Transition Risks
- Not disclosed
Opportunities
- Investing in renewable energy.
Reporting Standards
Frameworks Used: GRI, SASB
Certifications: Null
Third-party Assurance: Not disclosed
UN Sustainable Development Goals
- Not disclosed
Not disclosed
Sustainable Products & Innovation
- Not disclosed
Awards & Recognition
- 2019 SuperReturn Award for Achievement in Promoting Diversity
- Perfect score in the Human Rights Campaign Corporate Equality Index
Reporting Period: 2020-01 to 2020-12
Environmental Metrics
ESG Focus Areas
- Sustainable growth
- Climate resilience
- Strong stakeholder ties
- Engaged employees
- Diverse and inclusive teams
Environmental Achievements
- Achieved fourth year of carbon neutrality across corporate activities
- Completed bottom-up carbon footprinting for majority-owned companies in US, Europe, and Asia Buyout strategies
- 284,521 MTCO2e of CO2e avoided from the grid through renewable energy investments
- Novolex announced a goal of reducing its GHG emissions intensity by 20% by 2025 (12% already achieved)
Social Achievements
- Published 100% score for the fourth year in a row on the HRC Corporate Equality Index
- Partnered with 100+ organizations to address the impact of COVID-19 on vulnerable communities
- More than 80% of employees participated in unconscious bias training
- 63% of new hires in the U.S. were women or ethnic minorities; 58% of new hires in Europe and 52% in Asia were women
- Expanded board diversity goal to 30% of all directors in Corporate Private Equity-controlled portfolio companies by 2023
- PPD realized more than $13 million in plan savings (15% decrease in projected costs) through healthcare benefits redesign
- Pharmapacks enhanced capabilities through improved organizational design and additional talent
Governance Achievements
- Published first Taskforce on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) report
- Became a founding member of the One Planet Private Equity Funds Initiative
- Secured $6.5 billion in ESG-linked financings, including the largest ESG-linked U.S. private equity line of credit ($4.1 billion) tied to 30% diverse directors on boards within two years of ownership
- Revised and refreshed firmwide ESG Policy and Investment Exclusions and Parameters policy
Climate Goals & Targets
- Not disclosed
- Not disclosed
- Not disclosed
Environmental Challenges
- Credit investments present unique challenges for ESG integration due to higher deal volume, shorter diligence windows, less access to management and data, and fewer high-quality ESG tools.
- Dynamic materiality in ESG requires constant adaptation to evolving issues.
- COVID-19 pandemic presented challenges in various aspects of business operations and stakeholder engagement.
Mitigation Strategies
- Developed a proprietary ESG materiality analysis tool for Global Credit platform using SASB standards and country-level ESG risk data sets.
- Strengthened firm’s governance on sustainability with regular updates to the Carlyle Board of Directors.
- Expanded dedicated ESG and Impact team globally.
- Partnered with portfolio companies to navigate disruptions and implement agile strategies.
- Provided resources and support to portfolio companies to address challenges related to COVID-19 and cybersecurity.
Supply Chain Management
Supplier Audits: Not disclosed
Responsible Procurement
- Application of principles, values, standards, and norms of behavior as summarized in our Code of Conduct
Climate-Related Risks & Opportunities
Physical Risks
- Sea level rise
- Extreme weather events
Transition Risks
- Regulatory changes
- Market shifts
Opportunities
- Renewable energy investments
- Energy efficiency improvements
Reporting Standards
Frameworks Used: GRI, SASB, TCFD, World Economic Forum's ESG metrics
Certifications: Null
Third-party Assurance: Not disclosed
UN Sustainable Development Goals
- Not disclosed
Not disclosed
Sustainable Products & Innovation
- Not disclosed
Awards & Recognition
- Not disclosed
Reporting Period: 2021-01 to 2021-12
Environmental Metrics
ESG Focus Areas
- Energy Transition
- Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI)
- Climate Change
Environmental Achievements
- 289 MW of renewable energy capacity installed
- Investments saved the equivalent of 39 million gallons of gas annually
- 75% of portfolio companies’ Scopes 1 and 2 emissions to be covered by Paris-aligned climate goals by 2025
- All new majority-owned portfolio companies to set Paris-aligned climate goals within two years of ownership (post 2025)
- Net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 across direct investments
Social Achievements
- Launched Carlyle DEI Leadership Network, a coalition of several portfolio companies’ CEOs
- Inaugural underwriter of The Milken Institute’s DEI in Asset Management Program
- 50+ portfolio company board seats filled with diverse executives since 2016
- 70% of Hexaware employees in APAC regions were recruited locally
- Hexaware spent over $1.5 million to support communities
Governance Achievements
- First major private equity firm to publish a Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) report (2020)
- Led the ESG Data Convergence Project with CalPERS (2021), with over 190 GPs and LPs participating
- Developed a systematic approach to crafting purpose-built ESG strategies for portfolio companies
- Developed a DEI Playbook for portfolio companies
- Implemented a board committee responsible for sustainability at Cepsa, including DEI efforts
Climate Goals & Targets
- Net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 across direct investments
- Not disclosed
- 75% of portfolio companies’ Scopes 1 and 2 emissions to be covered by Paris-aligned climate goals by 2025
- All new majority-owned portfolio companies to set Paris-aligned climate goals within two years of ownership (post 2025)
Environmental Challenges
- Challenges associated with converging on comparable, performance-based, meaningful, and quantitative ESG data
- Rising energy costs
- Increased customer sensitivity towards climate-friendly products
- Need for a roadmap to build an integrated energy and carbon management strategy
- Capital constraints and lack of capabilities to deploy comprehensive energy solutions
Mitigation Strategies
- ESG Data Convergence Project to standardize ESG metrics
- Energy-to-Carbon Management Playbook to help improve existing energy and carbon management programs
- Partnership with portfolio companies to develop ESG initiatives and strategies
- EaaS delivery model to help meet the growing demand for sustainable energy systems
- Partnership with Cepsa to develop a business strategy to reduce emissions and increase diversity
Supply Chain Management
Supplier Audits: Not disclosed
Responsible Procurement
- Supplier Code of Conduct
- Code of Conduct
Climate-Related Risks & Opportunities
Physical Risks
- Not disclosed
Transition Risks
- Not disclosed
Opportunities
- Investing in opportunities created by the energy transition
Reporting Standards
Frameworks Used: GRI Standards, World Economic Forum’s ESG metrics, SASB Asset Management & Custody Activities Standards, TCFD
Certifications: Null
Third-party Assurance: Not disclosed
UN Sustainable Development Goals
- Not disclosed
Not disclosed
Sustainable Products & Innovation
- Not disclosed
Awards & Recognition
- Not disclosed
Reporting Period: 2022
Environmental Metrics
ESG Focus Areas
- Climate Change
- Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI)
- Governance
Environmental Achievements
- 833MW renewable energy capacity installed as of December 31, 2022
- 22 portfolio companies have set Paris-Aligned Climate Goals
- Operational carbon neutrality achieved for the 6th consecutive year
Social Achievements
- 27% increase in DEI award nominations in 2022
- 340+ portfolio company board seats filled with diverse directors as of March 31, 2023
- Launched DEI Leadership Network for portfolio company CEOs
Governance Achievements
- Established firmwide climate goals, including Net Zero by 2050
- Developed seven ESG playbooks for portfolio companies
- Over $25 billion in cumulative ESG-linked financings secured
Climate Goals & Targets
- Net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 or sooner across Direct Investments
- Various portfolio company specific goals
- 75% of In-Scope Companies’ Scopes 1 and 2 emissions covered by Paris-Aligned Climate Goals by 2025
Environmental Challenges
- Obtaining comprehensive data to accurately measure emissions
- Competing for budget and resources among corporate priorities
- Locating economically viable low-carbon reduction technologies
Mitigation Strategies
- Providing guidance and support to portfolio companies
- Activating third-party vendors for support
- Assisting in structuring decarbonization-linked financings
Supply Chain Management
Responsible Procurement
- Supplier Code of Conduct
Climate-Related Risks & Opportunities
Physical Risks
- Extreme weather events
- Chronic shifts in climate patterns
Transition Risks
- Policy and legal risks
- Technology risks
- Market risks
- Reputation risks
Opportunities
- Investment in renewable and sustainable energy
Reporting Standards
Frameworks Used: GRI, TCFD, WEF
Reporting Period: 2023
Environmental Metrics
ESG Focus Areas
- Climate Change
Climate Goals & Targets
- Net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 or sooner
Supply Chain Management
Climate-Related Risks & Opportunities
Reporting Standards
Frameworks Used: TCFD